Working Out While Sore: When to Train and When to Rest

Working out while sore is usually fine. Use a 0-10 soreness check to train, go light or rest, and see which recovery methods held up in research.

PushSlayer Editorial Team · Updated · 6 min read

Leer en español
A woman in a blue tracksuit grimaces as she stretches toward her foot on a grass field
Image by RyanMcGuire from Pixabay

Working out while sore is usually fine. Mild soreness, the stiff, achy kind that shows up a day or two after a new or harder workout, is not a reason to skip training. In a trial where people repeated a hard arm workout 2 and 4 days later, while still sore, the extra sessions did not add muscle damage or slow recovery. What changes is how hard you go: when soreness limits how you move, train other muscles or keep the sore ones light for a day or two. Rate your soreness below to decide.

Should you work out when sore? A 0-10 check

Yes, if the soreness eases once you warm up; if it doesn't, lower the load or switch muscles. Rate the sore muscle from 0 to 10 after a 5-10 minute warm-up, then use the row that matches. The warm-up matters: light movement cut soreness by about 40% for a while in one small trial, so a muscle that loosens up is telling you something different from one that doesn't.

Soreness after warm-upWhat it feels likeWhat to do today
0-3, mildStiff on stairs or when pressed, fades as you moveTrain as planned
4-6, moderateStill sore after the warm-up, hard to reach full rangeTrain other muscles, or train the sore one with half your usual sets at an easy effort
7-10, severeEveryday moves like sitting down or lifting your arms hurtRest that muscle; walk or cycle easily if you want to move
Possible injurySharp pain that started during the workout, pain in a joint, or bruisingStop and see a doctor or physiotherapist
Urgent warning signsSevere muscle pain or unusual weakness together with dark, tea- or cola-colored urineStop and get medical care right away

The warm-up length, the cut-offs in this table, the half-sets and reps-left targets, and the session lengths later in this article are our coaching rules, built on the research below. The idea behind them comes from a 2003 review of soreness treatments in Sports Medicine: people who train daily should reduce the intensity and duration of exercise for 1-2 days after a workout that caused intense soreness, or train less affected body parts instead.

Does working out while sore make it worse?

Not for mild to moderate soreness, as far as the research shows: training while sore did not add damage in the one trial that tested it directly. In the 2002 study by Nosaka and Newton, people did 3 sets of 10 slow lowering curls with one arm, then repeated the session 2 and 4 days later, while still sore. Compared with the other arm, which did the workout once, the repeated sessions did not change strength loss, range of motion, soreness or a blood marker of muscle damage. It was a small study of one arm muscle, so treat it as a strong hint, not proof for every workout.

The catch is quality. The Sports Medicine review notes that soreness can reduce range of motion and peak force and change the way muscles are recruited. Its authors warn these compensations may raise the risk of further injury if you return to hard training too soon. In practice: if soreness changes how a squat or push-up looks, the set is not worth doing at full effort.

Why your muscles are sore and how long it lasts

Soreness that starts the day after training is called delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS), and it typically peaks 48-72 hours after the workout. A 2018 review describes it as a mild form of muscle injury caused by unfamiliar exercise or eccentric work, the lowering phase of a movement. It brings temporary loss of strength, stiffness and sometimes swelling.

Lactic acid is not the leading explanation. The Sports Medicine review lists it as one of six proposed theories and says a combination of them likely explains soreness, while the 2018 review names tiny damage to muscle fibers, followed by local inflammation, as the primary mechanism. The Sports Medicine review also found DOMS most common when people return after a break or try a new type of exercise.

That explains the usual triggers:

  • Your first week back after time off
  • A new exercise, or more reps than usual
  • Workouts heavy on lowering: downhill running, slow negatives, lunges
  • A big jump in volume, like going from 20 push-ups to 100

What to do on a sore day

Pick the option that fits your rating from the table. Each keeps you training without loading the sorest muscle hard.

  1. Train a different area. Sore legs after squats? Do push-ups and core work. Sore chest and arms? Squat, lunge or walk.
  2. Go light on the sore muscle. Do half your usual sets and stop every set with at least 4 reps left. This matches the review's advice to reduce intensity and duration for 1-2 days.
  3. Move easily. A 20-30 minute walk or easy bike ride counts. The relief is real but short: in the 2006 trial, light exercise eased soreness right after each session but did not speed recovery of strength.
  4. Rest. With severe soreness, a day off that muscle group costs you little. It's also a good night to protect your sleep; here is how sleep affects muscle recovery.

If you train the same muscles often, the daily push-up guide and the daily squat plan explain how to spread sets across the week so soreness stays mild.

How to relieve sore muscles faster

Massage did best in the research. A 2018 meta-analysis of 99 studies compared recovery methods after exercise. Massage, active recovery, compression garments, cold water immersion, contrast water therapy and cryotherapy all reduced soreness, by small to large amounts, and massage was the most effective for soreness and fatigue. Stretching and electrical stimulation had no significant effect.

MethodEffect on soreness in the research
MassageLargest reduction of the methods studied
Active recovery (easy movement)Reduced soreness; relief may be short-lived
Compression garmentsReduced soreness and perceived fatigue
Cold water or contrast water immersionReduced soreness
Foam rolling after exerciseSmall reduction in muscle pain
StretchingNo significant effect

Foam rolling is a cheap version of massage. A 2019 meta-analysis of 21 studies found that rolling after exercise reduced muscle pain perception slightly; its small effects on sprint and strength recovery were not statistically significant. The authors called the effects minor overall and saw more support for rolling as a warm-up.

The 2018 meta-analysis measured soreness, fatigue and blood markers, not how soon you can train hard again, and in the 2006 trial light exercise eased soreness without speeding strength recovery. Treat these methods as ways to feel better, and pick one you'll actually do: a few minutes of foam rolling or a cold-water soak.

Does soreness mean muscle growth?

No. Soreness tells you the workout was new or harder than usual, not that it worked. In an 8-week training study, one group eased into eccentric cycling over 3 weeks and never showed signs of muscle damage, while the other started hard and got sore. Both groups gained the same muscle size and strength: 25% and 26% stronger. It was a small study, but it shows you don't need to chase soreness to make progress.

Our coaching advice is to track the things that do show progress: more reps at the same form, a harder variation, or more weekly sets, as laid out in the beginner bodyweight workout program.

Why you'll get less sore every week

Your muscles adapt after the first hard session. This is called the repeated bout effect: a 2003 review describes how a single bout of eccentric exercise protects the muscle from damage in later bouts. The exact cause is still unsettled; proposed explanations include changes in the nerves, the muscle's structure and its inflammatory response.

You can use that on purpose. The Sports Medicine review recommends introducing new or eccentric exercises progressively over 1-2 weeks. A simple version for a new program:

WeekSets per exerciseEffort
11-2Stop with 4-5 reps left
22-3Stop with 3-4 reps left
3 and onFull programStop with 1-3 reps left

That ramp is our coaching template. Expect a little soreness in week one anyway; it fades as the program becomes familiar.

When soreness is a sign of injury

Normal soreness is a generalized ache in the muscles you trained that peaks within 2-3 days and, according to a 2013 consensus statement on muscle injuries in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, usually resolves on its own within a week. The same statement describes muscle tears differently: sharp, stabbing pain at the moment of injury, often with a felt "snap", pain in one well-defined spot, and sometimes bleeding in the muscle that shows as a bruise. See a doctor or physiotherapist instead of training through it when you notice:

  • Sharp or stabbing pain that started suddenly during the workout, especially with a snap
  • Pain in one well-defined spot, or bruising over the muscle
  • Pain in a joint rather than the muscle, which doesn't fit the soreness pattern
  • Soreness that hasn't cleared after a week, or keeps you from normal daily movement for days

One warning sign needs care right away. Severe muscle pain or unusual weakness together with dark, tea- or cola-colored urine can point to rhabdomyolysis, a breakdown of muscle tissue. The CDC advises stopping activity, drinking water and seeking immediate care at the nearest medical facility, asking to be checked for rhabdomyolysis.

The short version

Warm up, then rate the sore muscle. At 0-3, train as planned. At 4-6, train other muscles or keep the sore ones light for a day or two. At 7 or above, rest that area and walk. Massage or foam rolling can take the edge off, and soreness will shrink on its own as your body gets used to the program.

Floor 1 is waiting.

Download PushSlayer for iPhone and try the introductory fight. Sign in and subscribe for full access.

Download on the App Store

Keep reading